iSpy – spooks, social media & sarcasm

Published: June 6, 2014

“It seems the spooks want to know whether you are being sincere when you tweet...”

On Monday this week the US Secret Service posted a tender which, among other things, solicits bids for social media analytics software that has the “ability to detect sarcasm”. It seems the spooks want to know whether you are being sincere when you tweet “God I just love having all my online activities monitored by the US intelligence services!” or if you’re cloaking your disdain using words that mean the exact opposite of what they say, like some kind of verbal ninja.

I’ll admit I’m struggling with the idea of how it will actually work. I took the opportunity to look through some recent sarky comments, particularly prevalent on Twitter during hashtag-hijacks like #WhyImVotingUKIP or #AskBG, and what became apparent is that sometimes I can’t tell if people are being serious or not. I could expand on what that means about UKIP voters in another blog, but what I mean here is that if even someone with a decent grasp of dry British humour can’t tell whether something’s sarcastic or not, how are you meant to construct an algorithm to find out?

One of the reasons this is difficult is because sarcasm is the backbone of social media. Most of what’s said online, at least in Britain and certainly on Twitter, is said with a tinge of verbal irony. I regularly see people visibly chuckle to themselves as they send their carefully-crafted 140-character missives. The ubiquity of sarcasm on social media explains why it’s so elusive to sentiment analysis software.

It’s important to remember that whether you’re monitoring for sarcasm, or just plain ‘positive’ and ‘negative’ comments, the principles of good sentiment analysis remain the same. The process will only be helpful if social insights specialists are asking the right questions. This point was touched on in an interesting webinar I listened in on last week, Understanding Context & Sentiment Analysis, hosted by Gorkana’s Lead Consultant for Social Media Insights, Alistair Wheate. Alistair’s main point was that just knowing whether messages are positive or negative, or in this case sarcastic, is not useful. Context is king, so asking good questions is essential.

Let me demonstrate the point. If the Secret Service wanted to use sarcasm-detecting software for their own Twitter presence, they might want to drill down into the data to find out: are people more or less sarcastic about the Secret Service than they are of, say, MI6? How sarcastic are people about intelligence services as a whole as compared to other sectors like telecoms companies? (“It’s just dandy that I don’t get signal in my central London home.”) How does this vary when you’re looking at comments about PRISM versus comments about career options? Asking the right questions makes big data valuable.

And of course ultimately, if you have to build software to understand the joke, the joke probably is on you.

Madeleine Crowther
Junior Consultant

Gorkana’s next session in the Social Insights series is on Tuesday 10 June – Using social media analysis to discover the issues of tomorrow.

Leave a Reply

Name *

Mail (not published) *

Comment

* Required field

Case Study: Grant Thornton International

“Building Thought Leadership”

International accounting and advisory company, Grant Thornton, differentiates itself as an organisation that works with dynamic...

Read more

Blog: PR Professionals Must Maintain A Leading Role

“We need to modernise and adapt to new digital trends, including measuring impact in real-time, but PR must stay true to its roots.”

Buzzword bingo was in full effect at the PRCA’s annual conference at BAFTA this year. Transparency, collaboration and...

Read more

Case Study: TheCityUK

Managing the reputation of one of the UK's largest industry sectors

TheCityUK is the membership body for the UK’s financial and related professional services industry. Its membership includes...

Read more

Case Study: British Gas

“Energy efficiency in social housing: making the green deal work”

British Gas is the UK’s leading energy and home services provider. Local authority and housing association decision makers...

Read more

Newswire: Linstock gets first prize!

“Linstock and UK Community Foundations won Not for Profit Campaign of the Year 2013 Award at Golden Hedgehogs!”

We’re proud to announce that Linstock Communications and our client UK Community Foundations have been awarded the Golden...

Read more

Blog: Typologies: Melancholic May Versus Choleric Boris

“With typologies becoming increasingly popular in business literature, let's investigate why and whether such conceptual frameworks can always be trusted.”

Apply the four temperaments typology to big names in Brexit and you might go with Phlegmatic Phil, Melancholic May and Choleric...

Read more