Three is a Magic Number

Published: May 9, 2014

“You may have a host of compelling reasons to choose your product or service that you’d like to let people know about, but mentioning them all may actually lead consumers to discount your proposition entirely.”

Three is a magic number for the communications profession. To me, three has always just felt… right. I try to keep to three key points when I give presentations. I normally make three arguments in the blogs and essays I write. And yes, there have even been times when I’ve sat staring at my screen trying to think of a third, largely unnecessary, adjective that’ll really make a sentence pop. (And I just gave three examples, if you don’t count this one.)

A recent study sheds some light on why I’m not alone in my triadic obsession. US behavioural scientists Kurt A. Carlson and Suzanne B. Shu wanted to know how many positive claims should be used in marketing messages. They specifically looked at scenarios where people know they are trying to be persuaded by a product, service or argument – like reading new packaging for breakfast cereal, listening to a politician give a speech or even talking with a friend about rekindling a failed relationship with an ex-boyfriend. They then varied the number of positive claims used in the scenarios, from one to six.

What they found is that when up to three reasons are given people are likely to believe them. So when your friend tells you she is getting back with her old flame because he’s “intelligent, kind and funny” you assume he’s a catch. But when your friend says she’s together with her high school sweetheart again because he’s “intelligent, kind, funny and cute” you start wondering whether she’s kidding herself about him.

Similarly, when a cereal box’s packaging tells you that the brand is now “healthier, better tasting, crunchier, and with higher quality ingredients” you sniff a sales motive and are sceptical. But if the packaging uses just three of these claims, you are more likely to conclude that the cereal inside really is healthier, better tasting and crunchier. The conclusion is: if you use any more than three positive claims, people dismiss your message as too try-hard. Carlson and Shu called this effect the ‘charm of three’.

The lesson for marketing and communications professionals (as well as reconnected lovers) is: don’t overload your messages with positive claims. You may have a host of compelling reasons to choose your product or service that you’d like to let people know about, but mentioning them all may actually lead consumers to discount your proposition entirely. Stick to just three if you want to persuade.

Madeleine Crowther
Junior Consultant

Leave a Reply

Name *

Mail (not published) *

Comment

* Required field

Newswire: Linstock gets first prize!

“Linstock and UK Community Foundations won Not for Profit Campaign of the Year 2013 Award at Golden Hedgehogs!”

We’re proud to announce that Linstock Communications and our client UK Community Foundations have been awarded the Golden...

Read more

Case Study: Grant Thornton International

“Building Thought Leadership”

International accounting and advisory company, Grant Thornton, differentiates itself as an organisation that works with dynamic...

Read more

Case Study: TheCityUK

Managing the reputation of one of the UK's largest industry sectors

TheCityUK is the membership body for the UK’s financial and related professional services industry. Its membership includes...

Read more

Blog: PR Professionals Must Maintain A Leading Role

“We need to modernise and adapt to new digital trends, including measuring impact in real-time, but PR must stay true to its roots.”

Buzzword bingo was in full effect at the PRCA’s annual conference at BAFTA this year. Transparency, collaboration and...

Read more

Blog: Typologies: Melancholic May Versus Choleric Boris

“With typologies becoming increasingly popular in business literature, let's investigate why and whether such conceptual frameworks can always be trusted.”

Apply the four temperaments typology to big names in Brexit and you might go with Phlegmatic Phil, Melancholic May and Choleric...

Read more

Case Study: British Gas

“Energy efficiency in social housing: making the green deal work”

British Gas is the UK’s leading energy and home services provider. Local authority and housing association decision makers...

Read more