What should an impartial BBC look like?

Published: March 20, 2014

“But what do we really mean by impartiality, and what should that look like for the BBC and other public broadcasters? ”

Maybe it’s just me, but criticism of the BBC for a lack of impartiality seems to be increasing. Whether it’s coverage of the Scottish and EU independence referendums, stories relating to climate change or the screening of programmes related to charity campaigns, many people seem to believe the BBC is failing to live up to its commitment to be impartial.

But what do we really mean by impartiality, and what should that look like for the BBC and other public broadcasters?

Many of the BBC’s critics provide evidence of bias in the form of ratios, citing the number of spokespeople interviewed for or against their pet issue. So a professor in media politics from the University of the West of Scotland recently highlighted data showing the BBC’s main evening news broadcasts in Scotland have a 3:2 ratio of statements supportive of independence versus those supportive of the union.

This argument suggests the BBC should be aiming for a 1:1 ratio of pro and anti statements on all issues. But while we may think that sounds fair, imagine what it would look like in reality.

For every debate on immigration the views of the BNP and EDL would need to be represented alongside those of the more mainstream parties. For every story about floods in the UK, the views of those like David Silvester who believe they are a consequence of allowing gay marriage would be given equal weight to scientists talking about climate change or lack of dredging. And campaigners in favour of creationism being taught in school science lessons would be given as much prominence as those promoting the theory of evolution.

As the BBC’s guidelines state, impartiality does not require absolute neutrality. Where there is a weight of scientific evidence or public opinion for a particular viewpoint, maybe it’s ok for the broadcaster to tip the scales in favour of spokespeople championing those opinions.

Yes, it’s vital that minority views are not ignored and that those with opinions that differ from the norm are not brushed aside by the press, but let’s cut the BBC some slack and remember that objectivity is about more than a just a ratio.

Jo Nussbaum is a Senior Consultant at Linstock Communications.

Leave a Reply

Name *

Mail (not published) *

Comment

* Required field

Blog: How to Avoid a January Fail: Nurture Your Collective Ambition

Senior Consultant

“How can corporate communications professionals prevent January from getting the better of us?”

Studies show that less than 8% of people actually achieve their New Year’s resolutions. Most of us set too many goals, without...

Read more

Case Study: Equal Approach

“Big impact on a small budget: tightly targeted communications”

Equal Approach came to Linstock with a clear objective: help them sign up 500 volunteers with The Mentoring and Befriending...

Read more

Blog: The Big Diversity Panto: It’s behind you! Oh no it isn’t!

“According to Grant Thornton, the number of women occupying senior business roles in the UK has moved just three percentage points in a decade and stands at a measly 22%. ”

As the high-street fills with festive shoppers and Slade blasts from the kitchen radio, I draw my own yuletide comfort from a...

Read more

Case Study: TheCityUK

Managing the reputation of one of the UK's largest industry sectors

TheCityUK is the membership body for the UK’s financial and related professional services industry. Its membership includes...

Read more

Newswire: Class Ceilings

“End-of-term report for UK plc shows state-schooled pupils still struggle to make it to the top of big business.”

A new report by a Linstock client, the diversity consultancy Equal Approach, shows that big business is still an old boys’...

Read more

Case Study: Harborough

“Managing reputation during transformational change”

Local authorities across the country are grappling with the challenges of budget cuts and a more localist approach. Linstock...

Read more